| NOTE: This proposal is only about Black Hole from the non-canon "If Among Us Was A BFDI Challenge" short, as his canon counterpart from the main Battle For Dream Island series doesn't qualify as Inconsistently Heinous. |
Never though there would be a version of this guy that qualifies, but I guess anything is possible after all.
| “ | Black Holes always win in the end. | „ |
| ~ A sad fact of life. |
Hello everyone and welcome to my eleventh Inconsistently Heinous Proposal. With the success that was my collaboration on the Blitz proposal, I'd like to turn my attention for a bit to a type of media I love, that being object shows, especially Battle for Dream Island. Indeed, I have quite a few candidates from them I want to propose, with a certain yellow bastard and a British piece of Mexican cuisine being my primary targets at the moment, but before that, I wanted to do a quick, short proposal on a candidate from the series that I believe has been overlooked.
Our candidate for today/night is Black Hole from a non-canon Battle for Dream Island short known as If Among Us Was a BFDI Challenge. Without further ado, let's get into it.
What's The Work?
If Among Us Was a BFDI Challenge is non-canon Battle for Dream Island short that parodies the 2018 hit multiplayer video game of the same name. It follows some of the show's cast as they navigate across the Skeld while interacting with various tasks found in the game all while there are Imposters trying to kill them (which doesn't matter since both only have one scene of screen time each and everyone dies at the end anyway).
Who Is He? What Has He Done?
Black Hole is the overarching antagonist of the Battle for Dream Island short, If Among Us Was a BFDI Challenge.
He is a sentient black hole that appears at the end of the video and sucks up everyone after their ship disappears.
So, at the end of the video Eraser and Coiny are in the Cafeteria, still unsure on what the Emergency Button does from earlier in the video, until the former decides to press it. The button calls everyone onboard the Skeld and Eraser awkwardly declares that ships shouldn't exist in this BFDI world, which causes the ship to disappear and everyone to fall into Black Hole, who doesn't at all seem to mind that he just killed 63 (or 62) people.
Mitigating Factors.
Nah. This version of Black Hole is a far cry from the pacifist he in the canon series, and thanks to his limited screen time, he doesn't have any redeeming qualities.
Heinous Standard.
Sets it. The video is non-canon to the rest of Battle for Dream Island, meaning that the heinous standard is much lower with the only other villains in the video (Tennis Ball and X) getting only one person killed each (even if brutally) compare to Black Hole's 63 (62 if you discount Book, who isn't seen when everyone gets sucked up despite being on the ship previously) murders, which are more than enough to pass the video and Among Us baseline. He also evidently shows no remorse for his actions.
What Makes Him Inconsistent?
He is too too comedic to be PE or NPE as the video is an Among Us parody with even his worst action being played for laughs.
He also lacks enough characterization due to only appearing at the very end and having only one line of dialogue that doesn't tell us anything about him.
Final Verdict?
I'd give him an easy yes, but what do you think?