Inconsistently Heinous Wiki

To vote for the Inconsistently Heinous Proposals of the day, see:

  1. Lady McDeath from Monica's Gang - Ends January 24th
  2. Mr. Burton from Bully (2006 Video Game) - Ends January 24th

To vote for the Inconsistently Heinous Discussions of the day, see:

  1. Needs More Votes: USAball from Live and Let Die - Ends January 24th
  2. Roy from Saturday Night Live - Ends January 24th

To vote for the Inconsistently Heinous Removals of the day, see:

  1. TBA

READ MORE

Inconsistently Heinous Wiki
Rick Mature

"Mature Content Warning!"
‎The article contains some content involving a mature subject or situation and may not be suitable for younger viewers. If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page.

You thought Koopa worked alone?
~ Luigi revealing his true colors to Mario, and his famous quote.
I HATE YOU.
~ Luigi's message to Mario, foreshadowing his hatred for him.

Luigi is the main antagonist of the "I HATE YOU" Creepypasta and the Super Mario World ROM Hack of the same name.

He is a deceitful, treacherous former hero who grew weary of constantly living in Mario's shadow. Eventually joining himself with Bowser, Luigi endeavors to kill his own brother, Mario. However, his efforts prove futile as Mario ends up killing Luigi by knocking him into lava, and thus transforming him into a charred, yet animated, corpse.

His Evil Ranking[]

What Makes Him Heinous?[]

  • He allies himself with Bowser after being fed up of being Mario's "second banana" for years.
  • Killed Mario several times over in cruel ways, such as crushing him to death with raging Thwomps and drowning him, with the residue of his previous kills being seen around his castle.
  • Despite working with Bowser, he vandalizes one of his walls just to let Mario know how much he hates him.
  • When Mario arrives, he sadistically reveals that he was always working for Bowser, which understandably horrifies him.
  • He ruthlessly attacks his own brother, even proudly standing over him after believing he's won. This, in turn, forces Mario to fight back in self defense and push him into the lava below them.
  • Had Luigi won, not only would he have killed his brother, but he would have helped Bowser take over the Mushroom Kingdom with ease. Furthermore, he would have been hurting his own friends.
  • Despite joining Bowser, he never shows that he cares about him as he only works with him for pragmatic reasons in order to cheat his way to victory.
  • While it was understandable that Luigi felt pushed to the side from his brother's fame, it's too laughable and petty of an excuse to be considered tragic, especially since he was willing to betray everyone he had known for the sake of having the spotlight.
  • Despite his death being incredibly horrific, it was painted for satisfaction and a fitting punishment for attempting to kill his brother. If anything, the sympathy goes to Mario, who genuinely loved Luigi despite his betrayal and accidentally killed him out of self defense. Even then, Mario still mourned his death.
    • In the SNES version, he is still not played for any sympathy, as Mario was forced to fight him out of self-defense, not to mention he's the one who started the fight.
  • While his screentime is short as he only appears at the near end of the story, he still shows enough personality, such as arrogance and sadistic pleasure in hurting Mario.
  • Although one could say he's just a bog-standard "kill the heroes" villain, this is debunked as his motive of killing Mario over and over again is purely out of spite, not because he views him as a threat. Not only that, he also willingly helped Bowser in his plans to take over Mushroom Kingdom, planning to betray or even hurting his other friends like Peach or Yoshi, preventing him from being bog standard.

What Makes Him Inconsistent?[]

  • Despite having no redeeming qualities, this Luigi is from a trollpasta, which is a comedic parody work to mock other video game Creepypastas, therefore he was never meant to be taken all that seriously.

Trivia[]

External Links[]

Navigation[]

           Super Mario Logo Inconsistently Heinous

Video Games
Marioverse
Bowser | Waluigi | MegaBug | Lucien

TV Shows
King Koopa | King K. Rool

Comics
Bowser

Manga
Yoshi

Fanon
Versions of Mario
Dorkly | Luigi's Day Out | Mario.exe | Mario Goes Berserk | Mario is Mental | MoBrosStudios | Racist Mario | Secret History | SMG4
Versions of Luigi
I HATE YOU | Luigi's Lament | Mario and Luigi: Super Anime Brothers
Versions of Waluigi
SMG4 | The All Powerful Waluigi | The Cursed Cap Saga | Waluigi Vs. Smash Bros
Others
Alice Aduraice | Bowser (Luigi's Lament) | Bowser Junior (SML YTP: Junior's Nuke) | Bowser Junior (Glider YTP: Bowser Junior The Murderer) | Bruno Gate | Chef Pee Pee | Cody Nutkiss | Frieza | Froger | Gonzo | Lawyer Kong | Mojo Jojo | Mr. Puzzles | Princess Peach (Peach's Revenge) | SMG3 | SMG4 (SMG4 SHORTS ARE MOVING!)| Spamton G. Spamton | Tari | Box Club Leader | The Frog Chief | Wario | Yoshzilla | Ztar

See Also
Nintendo Inconsistently Heinous | Paper Mario Inconsistently Heinous | SMG4 Inconsistently Heinous | SML Inconsistently Heinous

           Creepypasta Inconsistently Heinous

Notable Creepypastas
Jeff the Killer | Laughing Jack | Z̤͂â̢ḷ͊g̹̓ȯ̘

Fanfics
Demonic Sailor Moon
YouTube
Alex Kralie | Clem Puckett

Video Game Creepypastas
Sonic.EXE: Sarah Henderson | Scorched | Executor Vermillion | Sark | RE-RUN | Unnamed Serial Killer | Gene-X
Godzilla: Godzilla.EXE (Original | Sinzilla | Monster-G | Old Scratch)
Mario: Luigi (I HATE YOU) (Mario's Madness Lyrical Cover) | Mario.exe (Coolrash)
Other: LONLINESS