|
"Mature Content Warning!" |
| “ | Everyone thinks I've gone soft and lost my edge. I'll show them who's gone soft, I'll show them all! | „ |
| ~ Duncan vowing to get back at those who mistreated him, setting into motion the poop's events. |
Duncan is the titular protagonist villain of the 2021 YouTube Poop Total Drama YTP: Duncan Murders Chris made by MTV 2020.
He is a juvenile delinquent who participates in the titular reality TV show in hopes to win the one million dollars. Unlike his jerkish yet occasionally heroic canon counterpart, this Duncan becomes a deranged serial killer once he is abused and mocked by both of the show's hosts and even by his fellow campers.
He was voiced (through archive recordings) by Drew Nelson.
His Evil Ranking[]
Debated Validations[]
- Though he was raped under Chris McLean's orders by Chef Hatchet, given how the rape itself technically happens offscreen thanks to the show's censors and we only hear his screams, it's unknown how horrible it was, in addition that strangely, Duncan focuses more on killing his fellow campers and leaves Chef as his last victim.
- While offscreen, Word of God states that Duncan killed Eva, Katie, Sadie, Ezekiel, Bridgette, Gwen and Sierra offscreen. However, these statements don't count unless shown onscreen, although it's likely this is the case as Duncan mentions at the end that only he remains. It's also left undisclosed if he killed Cameron, who was present when Duncan heard how Chris planned to bring him back for another season.
What Makes Him Heinous?[]
- Threatens Chris McLean to by asking him to "eat d*ck" after Chris abducts him, which causes Chris to order his co-host Chef Hatchet to rape Duncan, likely traumatizing him before further taunting him by showing a video of Duncan mentioning how sad he was when his dog Petey ran away and crying for the rape, making Duncan the laughingstock of Camp Wawanakwa.
- Resolves to murder Chris for having him raped and getting Alejandro, Tyler, Noah, Izzy, Gwen and even his own girlfriend Courtney to cruelly laugh at him with the video and stating his intentions to bring Duncan back in a further season, which would likely involve something sexual due to the "C*cks vs. Bigger C*cks" name, in addition that Duncan felt that his teammates should remeber he isn't a "soft guy".
- Strikes Chris to death with an axe. While Chris certainly deserved it, Duncan killed him in a way his blood splattered over Owen, Lindsay, Izzy and DJ, much to their disgust.
- Although he seems to forget about his homicidal urges when all the campers, led by Owen, throw a celebration for Chris' date, Duncan goes back to kill when his archenemy Harold McGrady pranks him, Tyler witnesses his confrontation with the former and his girlfriend Courtney cheats on him with Alejandro Burromuerto:
- Guts Harold alive with a hook just because Harold put rocks in his matress to hurt his back during his sleep.
- Stalks Tyler once he realizes that Tyler witnessed him killing Harold, so when Tyler hides under the Dock of Shame to confide Lindsay what he saw, Duncan shoves a canoe on Tyler, crushing him to death, and then chases Lindsay until he sprains his ankle.
- Drowns Noah after he condenscendingly taunts him over Courtney cheating on him with Alejandro for spranining his ankle.
- Throws Owen off a cliff mentioning Noah's murder in the confessionary, leading Owen to be injured with different objects until Duncan blows him up with explosives he put in the cliff.
- Goes after Geoff and DJ, his former friends, and guts them alive as DJ tries to hide in the bathroom and Geoff stays outside to check if Duncan approaches them.
- Drags Alejandro up as he explores a cave and kills him with his own hands to get back at him for causing Courtney to leave him.
- Stabs Courtney with his carving knife for cheating on him.
- Disposes of Izzy and Leshawna offscreen through unknown means.
- Murders Heather while she was in the shower, which can count as sexual assault.
- Chainsaws a scared Lindsay to death.
- Poisons Trent with some kind of food and leaves him to convulse alone in the cafeteria's floor.
- Pushes Justin off a prop tower, sending him hundred of feet to his death, causing him to hit his head while falling.
- Sics a dinjo onto Cody, getting him knocked off a cliff to his death.
- Every once he kills someone, he crosses a drawing of them in a list, which he then burns once he states that no one but him remains alive at Camp Wawanakwa.
- Shoots an arrow at Chef when he comes to stop his killing spree with a bazooka, and while Chef avoids it, Duncan throws one of his kitchen knives to his groin, killing Chef (though he definitely had it coming for raping Duncan beforehand).
- Expresses zero remorse once he realizes that he has killed all of Camp Wawanakwa's population, showing happiness at the fact that no one will annoy him again and that he can win the million dollars without any competence.
- Gets arrested and send to prison for his actions, but finds a way to escape from it and as of this writing is on the loose, essentially getting away with his murders and possibly now planning to kill more people.
What Makes Him Inconsistent?[]
- He is from a YouTube Poop, so he isn't meant to be taken seriously due to being a parody. Most likely, the poop mocks the canon Duncan's flanderization into an "accidental nice guy" in the controversial fifth season.
- His crimes were all played for laughs and black comedy.
- He loves his mother and the show's fans, as he writes a letter to his mom while doing time and talks to the audience in a friendly way, in spite that the audience was likely the ones who called the police to take him into custody.
- He is a tragic villain, as he was never the same after his dog Petey's disappearance when he was just six years old and was raped just for insulting the show's host.
- At the very least, killing Chris McLean and Chef Hatchet was absolutely justified due to them torturing him. While Duncan may have been a troublemaker who annoyed both hosts like he does in canon, he didn't do anything to deserve being raped and traumatized. As for the rest of his kills, however, Duncan definitely overreacted over minor things.
- It's heavily implied that despite being laughed at by his fellow campers, Duncan was still friends with them, specifically with his girlfriend Courtney, as they cheered up for him when he kills Chris and would have likely left them alone if Harold hadn't pranked him and if Courtney hadn't left him for Alejandro.
Trivia[]
- Unironically, the canon version of Duncan is Inconsistently Admirable, the good opposite of Inconsistently Heinous.
External Links[]
[]
 Inconsistently Heinous
| ||
|
Canon Fanon | ||
 Inconsistently Heinous
| ||
|
SpongeBob SquarePants Sony Pictures Disney Mario Other | ||