Inconsistently Heinous Double Re-Proposal: Luigi and Bowser from Luigi's Lament
Just when I thought I wouldn't propose any more candidates previously proposed by untrustworthy users last year, I'm doing it again this year, this time it's because TheAverageDimentio, the original proposer for Luigi and discusser for Bowser, didn't actually see some of the works the characters she proposed and removed originated from, so all of her proposals got erased since it's unknown if she had seen the other works the characters she proposed and removed originated from. So, these two guys are being proposed again. Permission from Complete monster to make this double re-proposal here.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who are They? What Have They Done?
- 3 What Makes Them Heinous?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What Makes Them Inconsistent?
- 6 Verdict?
Luigi's Lament i…
IH Discussion: Rimuru Tempest (Forsaken Future)
I decided to do an another That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime Inconsistently Heinous and found another one in the ISEKAI Memories mobile game of an alternate version of Rimuru Tempest.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who's the character?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 3.1 Heinous Standard
- 3.2 Henious Acts
- 4 Why is he inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict
That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime: ISEKAI Memories is a moble game based on the That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime Light Novel series which had some original stories not found in Anime, Manga or original Light Novel.
Rimuru Tempest or specifically the Forsaken Future version of Rimuru Tempest is an alternate version of main character of the series where he fell against fight with Hinata and when he revived 3 years latter …
IH Proposal: Dr. Lawrence Gordon from the Saw Franchise
I supported him as Villainous Benchmark until I thought about his crimes and the heinous standard. Short proposal, yay, just need to go over the basics (that aged poorly).
Look, he definitely passes. If you disagree, you will have all these reasons to work against. I look forward to hearing your thoughts. Round yourselves up and give a yes to the doctor.
IH Proposal: MePhone4
I think he can qualify for the wiki.
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who Are They?
- 3 Heinous Standards?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 Final Verdict
Inanimate Insanity is a reality show similar to the likes of Total Drama and ESPECIALLY BFDI (which is the show's main inspiration, in fact) where object contestants compete to win a prize, 1 million dollars in Seasons 1 and 2, and something else for Season 3 (it was not specific until the very last episode of that series).
MePhone4 is the gameshow's host and the series' main protagonist come Season 2A, Season 3, and especially 2B (it's complicated, the last 4 episodes of Season 2 were chronologically after Season 3, and viewers will not get some scenes in those episodes if they didn't watch Season 3), with more emphasis o…
Double IH Removal: John Kreese and Terry Silver from Cobra Kai
I got permission from Complete Monster to make this removal back in February but never got around to doing it while the show was airing. Better late than never I guess, I'm hoping the fandom for it is still somewhat active so there's fair voting.
- 1 What is the Work?
- 2 Who Are the Characters?
- 2.1 John Kreese
- 2.2 Terry Silver
- 3 Why Don't They Count?
- 3.1 John Kreese
- 3.2 Terry Silver
- 4 Verdict
Cobra Kai is a Netflix spin-off/sequel to the karate kid that takes place in the present day when the main characters of the franchise have grown up. Daniel and Johnny's rivalry restarted after Johnny reopened Cobra Kai, leading to Daniel taking on Johnny's son as a student in response. This eventually led to Johnny's old teacher John Kreese returning, alongside karate o…
Mrs. Dubois: Inconsistently Heinous proposal
This MIGHT end up being my first rejected proposal but I feel like she deserves a discussion just due to how brutal she is.
- 1 What's the work
- 2 Who is Mrs. Dubios?
- 3 Heinous Standard?
- 4 What makes her Inconsistent?
- 5 Final verdict?
Hubie Halloween is a 2020 comedy movie by Adam Sandler. Yet this one is one of his better movies. Set in the town of Salem, Hubie's hated by pretty much the entire town. However, he still does his best to keep everyone safe. And he ends up being necessary for this specific Halloween when he finds himself looking for a REAL "killer".
The mother of the main protagonist, Mrs. Dubois is a protective single mother of her son. Mrs. Dubois loves Hubie but encourages her son to find his courage to stand up against his bullies. She s…
IH Proposal - Boris Anderson (Caillou Get Grounded The Movie)
Hello Everyone this is Dimey back again with a another GoAnimate Candidate and this time is Boris Anderson himself let get on with this shit
- 1 What The Work
- 2 Who is Boris Anderson and What Have He's Done
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 Preventions
- 5 Verdict
Caillou Get Grounded The Movie is 2017 film started our bald kid named Caillou who have to deal with his Father but for some reason ended up finding some lore from his dad just from his own therapy named Mr. Happy
Boris Anderson is the main villain of the film itself (duh), it ended up starting off with a dream where it start all of the Caillou's just chilling until Boris himself ended up shooting all of them
Caillou then got woke up by his Abusive Dad who tell him to get up for school and when Caillou got o…
IH Reproposal: Angel of Death (Undertale)
Well, it's been a long time since I made a proposal on this wiki, and with a candidate I didn't think would be approached again, but ok: thanks to RubyDoesStuff for giving me the permission to reproposal this.
It will have the same information as the original proposal, but with certain extra information (it's not plagiary, because I wrote the original proposal)
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who are they?
- 3 Actions and Heinous Standard
- 4 Mitigating actions
- 5 Why are they inconsistently?
- 6 Veredict:
I don't think I need to explain much, since it's quite famous with 4 proposals (update: 5) explaining it on this wiki alone, but in short, Undertale is a game in which a child falls underground full of monsters and has to escape, either by saving and making friends or …
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Blitzø Buckzo
This is our first time doing a collaboration proposal (and Snake Man 12.0's tenth proposal) and after taking a look at Helluva Boss, it's pretty obvious that Blitz is an easy keeper, given his lower resources since he is a mere imp who holds a small company involving killing humans on Earth.
Before I start the proposal, thanks to Snake Man 12.0 for collaborating with me on my proposal and let's begin!
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is Blitzø Buckzo? What He Has Done?
- 2.1 Background
- 2.2 Season 1
- 2.3 Season 2
- 2.4 Hellluva Shorts
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 5 Final Verdict?
Helluva Boss is an animated YouTube black comedy series created by VivziePop, serving as a spinoff series to Hazbin Hotel, with both series being a part of a shared universe kn…
IH Removal: Blocky
Well, it's that time again, time to come out of my cave and propose (or in this case, remove) someone! As some of you may know, object shows are my bread and butter. And here I am getting rid of the stabable menace himself, Blocky! Thanks to Bonus Person for allowing me to make this proposal.
Anywho, this was brought up in the clean-up server, with users questioning if he really qualifies. I might as well be the one to take him out myself. Not like any other character from an object show is ready for proposal since their arcs are still ongoing.
To be honest, I kind of have a weird relation with Blocky and his moral ranking. I believed he didn't qualify the first time around; his proposal was made and rejected. I later made his page on the Vi…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: ∆iden from ANOTHERFORESTER
Welp, guys, I found myself ANOTHERCANDIDATE from an FPE fanon work.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is She? What Has She Done?
- 3 What Makes Her Heinous?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What Makes Her Inconsistent?
- 6 Verdict?
ANOTHERFORESTER is a YouTube video by BlenTouad in 2024. It revolves Claire at the snowy forest being chased by ∆iden who's hunting her down. The video also has audio from the ' mod AnotherBrother. based on TWIDDLEFINGER based on the comedic YouTube channel MaxDesignPro.
∆iden is the main antagonist of the video. She is first seen chasing Claire while trying to shoot her with a shotgun. As Claire is running, she stumbles upon three brutalized corpses and Claire stumbles upon a river. ∆iden tries to shoot her but the shotgun is empty, so she, randomly star…
IH Proposal: Iciclia
After a friend of mine got me to binge the first two seasons of Atomic Betty on YouTube, I can safely say that Iciclia is another character in the show that can qualify thanks to not just one, but three of her actions. In the same episode as well!
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who's The Candidate?
- 3 Heinous Standards?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 Final Verdict
Atomic Betty has the titular character attend school in Moose Jaw Heights and save the entire galaxy from a large Rogues' Gallery (including Maximus I.Q., The Chameleon, Nuclea, Infantor, and today's candidate, Iciclia). The dilemmas always come from the fact that she has to balance both her activities on Earth and her heroics in outer space.
Iciclia is a major antagonist in the series, appearing in some epis…
IH Proposal: Geld
Yeah I decided to propose him as I originally thought he failed too hard where he is an Van Zant but after re-evaluating and persuasion from an friend who know the work like I do. I decided to try and propose to see if the heinous standard isn't too high for him to stand out. Here we go.
- 1 What is the work?
- 2 Who is he?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 3.1 Heinous Standard
- 3.2 Heinous Acts
- 4 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict
That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime is an light Novel about an worker who was reincarnated as a slime who formed an nation and befriended a dragon while trying to make a nation to enjoy his life enjoyable like in his old world. It also got Anime, Manga, and mobile & console games too.
Geld or nicknamed by Geld I and Geld Senior to di…
Future Freddy: Inconsistently Heinous proposal
Well this one should be short and simple.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is Future Freddy? What has he done?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 4 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 5 Final verdict?
ZAMination is a YouTube channel that does song's and musical's for popular indie animation show's, recently teaming up with Glitch Productions. Originally, they did content farm short's but as of recent, they're taking things more seriously as Fazebear and Friends episode 5 showed us. Speaking of that, let's get to our main antagonist.
Future Freddy is... well Freddy from the future. He comes to the present, warning the FNAF and TADC characters that the world is ending. He mentions all the non-FNAF character's not being in their correct world will spell the end for the universe. A…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: The Hamburglar (McDonald’s)
So uh first proposal in over two years. Don’t have much to say so let’s get into it.
- 1 The Work?
- 2 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 3 Heinous Standard
- 4 Inconsistencies?
- 5 Verdict?
McDonald’s is an American fast food company with like a gazillion restaurants everywhere. In addition to y‘know, food, they also own a media franchise called McDonaldland, featuring beloved clown Ronald McDonald and his gang of marketable friends like Grimace as they eat McDonald’s food and do whatever I guess.
The Hamburglar is the main antagonist here. The dastardly thief of McDonaldland, he spends his days trying to steal McDonald’s scrumptious meals from Ronald and co, though he almost always fails in these endeavors.
Okay so not gonna get into anything else as he’s extremely bo…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Mr. Puzzles from SMG4
Alright, everyone. Finally, the time this guy gets a proper IH proposal. Since he hasn't appeared yet (and probably never will) and there's no chance he would get worse or less bad (and also the fact that my NPE proposal on him got rejected), he should fit here nicely.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is He? What Has He Done?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 6 Verdict?
SMG4 is an Australian comedy web series by Luke and Kevin Lerdwichagul. It involves Mario, SMG4 and their friends going on various adventures meeting dangerous foes, including Mr. Puzzles, serving as their very arch nemesis.
Mr. Puzzles is a major antagonist in the series, specifically the main antagonist of The Showgrounds Era. He has, a lot of things h…
IH Proposal: Metal Sonic (Kuta9000)
Yeah I decided to do an Sonic IH and chosen a version of Metal Sonic from a YouTube Parody series.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is he?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 3.1 Heinous Standard
- 3.2 Heinous Acts
- 4 What makes him inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict
The Sonic, Shadow and Silver Show or SSS Show for short by some fans is an parody of Sonic, Shadow, Silver going on random adventures and getting into antics by many people on YouTube using still sprites, Speakonia, and real background images with numerous crossover characters such as Sailor Moon, Godzilla and etx.
Though there is true canon as it varies user to user so for this proposal it will be the videos by Kuta9000 for sake of consistency.
Metal Sonic or nicknamed Metal F*cker (Not making up and is only called it due …
IH Proposal: Billy from SML
Here with my second proposal. I haven't had any good ideas of new candidAIDS to propose since Void got approved back in January, but with the recent release of SML Movie: Billy Gets Cancelled!, I felt inspired to propose this guy.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who's the candidate?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 3.1 Saw
- 3.2 Saw 2
- 3.3 Saw 3
- 3.4 Billy's Revenge!
- 3.5 Billy Wants to Be Cool!
- 3.6 Billy Gets Cancelled!
- 3.7 Other appearances
- 4 What makes him inconsistent?
- 5 Heinous standards
- 6 Verdict
SML (formerly called SuperMarioLogan before series creator Logan Thirtyacre got sued by Nintendo) is a long-running YouTube web series that began airing in 2007. It started out as a plush channel, but has since evolved into a puppet show that frequently features appearances from live-action hum…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: The Fudge (The Amazing Digital Circus)
Hello everyone and welcome to my ninth Inconsistently Heinous proposal and my first proposal of the year 2025. As Jax is currently being discussed for here, I thought it would be a good idea to propose a character who wound up being one of the main reasons why he's able to stand out in the first place. And I'm not alone on this, as people I've talked with on Discord agree that it's fine to propose him now given that, like Jax, it's unlikely he'll be PE or NPE even if he does end up appearing again.
Our candidate for today is the chocolaty cannibal and former Candy Canyon Kingdom resident, The Fudge, from The Amazing Digital Circus. Without further ado, let's get into it.
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who Is He? What Has He Done?
- 3 Mitigating Factors.
- 4 Heino…
Jax (The Amazing Digital Circus): Inconsistently Heinous proposal
Well considering the fact he's on the "proposal's needed" list. I had a feeling ever since episode 2 he could count.
Disclaimer: It's widely agreed to be practically impossible for him to end up being taken seriously for PE or NPE, let alone the fact he has lines he won't cross and is troubled character who'll get more complex as well. So everyone agreed on discord it was okay to go ahead and propose him for this wiki despite his ongoing arc.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is Jax?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 4 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 5 Final verdict?
The Amazing Digital Circus is, to put it mildly, the biggest indie animation series ever created. Made by Glitch Productions alongside the creator Gooseworx, the series focuses a woman named Pomni who ends up…
Proposal Needed Page Has Been Made
Due to the list of potential IHs discussed on the cleanup server getting to the point of being extremely long (last time I checked there's over 300 characters listed as worth discussing alone) we have decided to create a new page for characters who have been discussed to warrant an IH proposal on there, but have not received a proposal yet, so the wider IH user base can see it.
However, due to concerns of people potentially hogging candidates on the list and turning the whole thing into a competition, we are going to only release a small amount of candidates to the greater IH community at a time. The list will contain a total of 20 candidates at once. After 10 candidates from the list have received a proposal, another 10 will be added, so o…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Whitty
Hello everyone and everywhere whoever was or will be, I’m and today I'm back with another Inconsistently Heinous proposal after quite some time. Today’s candidate is someone unexpected and may be one of the weirdest cases we’ve got on this wiki, but I want you all to first hear me out on this one.
Before going in i’d like to thank RubyDoesStuff for giving me permission to make this proposal
So with that out of the way, let’s jump right ahead and see what our candidate has done.
- 1 What’s the Work?
- 2 Who’s Whitty? What Has He Done?
- 3 Is He Heinous Enough?
- 4 Heinous Standard?
- 5 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 6 Conclusion?
Vs. Whitty Definitive Edition formerly known as Vs. Whitty Full Week in the legacy version is a mod of the popular 2020 rythm game Friday Nigh…
Kinito (KinitoPET) IH Proposal
Hello everybody! I am back with a rather... unique character. The character in question is named Kinito, not much else to say, so let's get to it
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is he?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 4 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 5 Heinous standards?
- 6 Conclusion
KinitoPET is an indie horror game created in 2024 by troy_en. It's about our unnamed protagonist who, on an early 2000s computer, downloads a PC Companion named "KinitoPET", and things quickly unfold from there. It starts rather innocently, with Kinito asking basic questions such as but not limited too; "What is your favorite color?" "What is your favorite game?" "What is your favorite food?". Later in the game, he invites you to meet his friends and play fun minigames, but things quickly…
IH Proposal: Ms. Stevenson
Okay so even though I've now returned to this wiki I wasn't planning on making a new proposal so soon. That was until I found out what exactly happened during this character's original proposal. I won't go into too much detail and I won't name names but I will make it clear that what happened there is an utter embarrassment to this wiki and as a result I believe we need to run this proposal back.
I will make it clear though, any attempts at trying to argue that the heinousness of this character is lessened by the fact their toddler victim "consented" will not be tolerated whatsoever. With that said, let's get on with the proposal.
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who is she? What has she done?
- 3 Mitigating Factors
- 4 heinous Standard
- 5 What Makes Her Inconsistent…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: The Invader
Alright, I'm back with another candidate, but this time from a recently released animated movie I just viewed known as The Day the Earth Blew Up. It's been nearly three weeks since the animated movie came out on theaters and without further introduction, let's dive right in.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is the Invader? What Has He Done?
- 3 Heinous Standard
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 5 Final Verdict?
The Day the Earth Blew Up: A Looney Tunes Movie is a 2025 animated film directed by Warner Bros. It focuses on the adventures of Daffy Duck and Porky Pig trying to fulfill their adoptive father's wish, Farmer Jim, of saving their childhood home by applying their jobs at a bubblegum factory, suggested by Petunia Pig, to have some money to repair the roof. L…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Mister Shapley from the Edgyverse
Sup, everyone. I can't believe I have another FPE candidate, fanon of course (since, well, no villain is actually inconsistent enough to qualify, and the ones that are don't do much to be heinous). After some examination, I found out that this guy EASILY qualifies as being Inconsistently Heinous. Let me introduce you to our astronomy teacher from outer space, Mister Shapley.
Also, this is only for his FPE counterpart, as his PPF counterpart has not done anything villainous as of now.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is He? What Has He Done?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 6 Verdict?
The Edgyverse is a universe by The Edgyverse (yes you read that right) which features her OCs just, going through some things, I guess. We'r…
IH Proposal - Caillou (Childish Dad: The Super Dave Bros Movie)
Hello Everyone this is Dimey of course back again with a another GoAnimate or Vyond candidate and this one is Caillou or Kayloou the four year old brat, let get with the king of the troublemaker
- 1 What The Work
- 2 Who is Caillou and What Have He's Done
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 Preventions
- 5 Verdict
Childish Dad The Super Dave Bros Movie is a certain of The Mario Movie but with The Childish Dad and his boyfriend Tinky Winky, Tinky Winky ended up getting separated by Dave and got taken by Caillou so now it up to Dave to bring back his boyfriend and stop Caillou madness as well
Caillou or KAYLOOU is the main villain of The Super Dave Bros Movie, we first see our certain bald kid and his troublemakers coming to the penguins castle and of course Caillou ended …
Double IH Proposal: Rudra Nam Ul Nasca & Michael
Rudra Nam Ul Nasca:
Michael:
Yep that's right another That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime IH since I did say the work has many IH candidates here and he is another one here. The leader of the Eastern Empire Rudra Nam Ul Nasca and his Manas Michael.
This is technically an two in one proposal since they share the same body.
One warning this will contain spoilers for the LN here.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who are They?
- 2.1 Rudra Nam Ul Nasca
- 2.2 Michael
- 3 What makes them heinous?
- 3.1 Heinous Standard
- 3.2 Heinous Acts
- 3.2.1 Rudra Nam Ul Nasca
- 3.2.2 Michael
- 4 Why are they inconsistent?
- 4.1 Both
- 4.2 Rudra Nam Ul Nasca
- 4.3 Michael
- 5 Important Note!
- 6 Verdict
- 6.1 Rudra Nam Ul Nasca
- 6.2 Michael
That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime is an light Novel about an worker who was reincarnated…
IH Proposal: Kirby (Dedede: Comin' At Ya!)
To celebrate April Fools Day, I have decided to do a proposal for a character that is very obviously not meant to be serious at all, yet still possible to count. Who is it?...
Y'know, I don't think we have enough versions of Kirby approved on this wiki, so how about another official one?
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is Kirby? What Does He Do?
- 3 Heinous Standard
- 4 Inconsistencies
- 5 Verdict
Dedede: Comin' At Ya! is in fact a cartoon within a cartoon. Specifically, it comes from the anime Kirby: Right Back At Ya! being part of the episode "Cartoon Buffoon". In that episode, King Dedede decides he wants to make a cartoon and hires all of Cappy Town to help him make it. Initially, Kirby was intended to be the hero, but Dedede alters the script to make himself th…
The Ink Demon (novels): Inconsistently Heinous proposal
Well with Bendy fans in limbo due to The Cage taking forever, as well as B3ndy and we have no idea when the movie is releasing. So let's go ahead and get another candidate approved in the mean time.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is the Ink Demon? What has he done?
- 3 What makes him heinous?
- 4 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 5 Final verdict?
Bendy is an extremely popular indie horror franchise, I'd say the 2nd most behind good old FNAF. There have been two main games, Bendy and the Ink Machine and Bendy and the Dark Revival. However, for this we're focusing on the novels; Dreams Come to Life, The Lost Ones and Fade to Black.
The Ink Demon has the same origin as his game counterpart. He's created by Joey Drew in a failed attempt to bring the cartoon Bendy alive. Due to his …
IH Proposal: Gorilla Grodd from DC’s Arrowverse
Back again with another proposal from the Arrowverse. This may seem like an unlikely candidate but I implore you to read the full proposal. I suck at introductions so let’s just get right into the proposal.
- 1 What’s The Work
- 1.1 What Has He Done
- 1.2 Mitigating Factors
- 1.3 Heinous Standards
- 1.4 Final Verdict
The Arrowverse is a continuity made up of different DC shows, such as Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl, Legends of Tomorrow, etc. Gorilla Grodd appears in Flash and Legends. The Flash is about Barry Allen, a crime scene investigator who uses his superhuman speed to fight criminals. Legends of Tomorrow is about a group of unorthodox time travelers.
Following the Particle Accelerator Explosion, Grodd achieved sentience and gained psychic powers. He escape…
IH Proposal: Satan (ANTONBLAST)
While I think Dynamite Anton is quite bog-standard, I think his game's main antagonist definitely passes the heinous standards.
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who Is He?
- 3 Heinous Standards?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 6 Final Verdict
ANTONBLAST is a platforming game based on the Anton series that started with the Antonball games, Antonball Classic, Punch Ball Antonball, and Antonball Deluxe. It's inspired by Wario Land 4, just like the game featuring a certain Italian chef that preceded it by one year.
Satan is the main antagonist of ANTONBLAST. He steals Dynamite Anton and Dynamite Annie's alcohol spirits to lure them into him so that he can siphon the "redness" out of Anton to become the reddest being on the planet. When they defeat hi…
Inconsistently Heinous Re-Proposal: The Projectionist from Bendy
Hello everyone, my first re-proposal of the year and my second re-proposal overall to be on a rejected candidate (he was approved but then got removed so he counts as that). I saw that this guy was once here but then he was removed due to failing the heinous standards. I used to agree with this, however, now I don't think that holds up. So, I'm re-proposing him. None of you are really expecting this but trust me, me neither. Please let me plead my case and don't blindly vote "no" due to the unexpected candidate. If you want to vote, please use all my points here first. Permission granted from Complete monster for me to make this re-proposal here.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is He? What Has He Done?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 4 Mitigating Factors?
- 5 What…
Double IH Proposal: Milim Nava and Veldora Tempest
Milim Nava:
Veldora Tempest:
That's right I am proposing an Non-Villain IH for once here but not just one Non-Villain but two Non-Villains so it's an double proposal here! So this probably makes it the first time someone did an double Non-Villain Proposal here. And I thought of doing the Mad Destroyer herself Milim Nava and the Storm Dragon Veldora Tempest from That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime an niece and uncle duo probably for first time in not only in IH History but Moral Ranking as well I think.
This is probably my biggest IH Proposal yet since Japanese Generation One Megatron since they are Non-Villains and I had to read the Light Novels to extract more detail which took more time and effort. So now reading more of the Light Novel I…
IH Proposal:King Quarren unos Santos from Starwatch
So the last proposal was a unanimous rejection. Alas, Quasimodo will not see this wiki. But today, I'm proposing a new character, and he's a king. But he's not a true villain, so he's bring brought here. (Thank you Complete Monster for granting permission for this one)
- 1 What is Starwatch?
- 2 Who is King Quarren unos Santos?
- 3 What makes him Heinous?
- 4 Heinous Standards?
- 5 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 6 Final Verdict?
Starwatch is a fanfiction story written by RealM1NEPR0, and it's technically a parody of Overwatch's Starwatch event, which in turn was a parody of space opera. Anyways. it's a story of a prince-becoming-king losing his people to the Galactic Emperor, and he sets out to stop his tirade on the nebula. The emperor is a clear villain, and Princ…
Vic Hoskins: Inconsistently Heinous removal proposal
With the Jurassic World franchise continuing on through the movie's and tv show's, and the heinous standard continuing to get higher, I feel this candidate doesn't qualify for this wiki. He's honestly one of the least evil villains alongside Ludlow. Thanks to Complete Monster for permission for this removal.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is he?
- 3 Why doesn't he count?
- 4 Final verdict?
Jurassic World is a 2015 film by made Universal that takes place decade's after the incident of Jurassic Park, where this time the theme park opened up. However, chaos ensues thanks to the escape of a hybrid dinosaurs, the Indominus-rex, the movie's main antagonist. However, we're focusing on the secondary antagonist for this proposal.
Vic Hoskins is the film's secondary antag…
IH Proposal: Betelgeuse from Beetlejuice
This is a proposal I've been wanting to make since the sequel Beetlejuice Beetlejuice came out, but due to being swamped in college work and also losing access to my previous account, I never got the chance. However, the day has finally arrived to propose everyone's favorite bio-exorcist. Since the original books, the cartoon, and the musical all exist within their own continuities, they will not be taken into account in this proposal.
- 1 What is the Work?
- 2 Who is the Character and What Has He Done.
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent
- 5 Verdict
Beetlejuice, and its 2024 sequel, follow the chaos that ensues with a man who died during the bubonic plague, and later became a bio-exorcist that removes humans from the homes of the deceased. He …
IH Proposal: Eya from Wandersong
Here we go. Wandersong deserves its characters to be morally scaled, and at least Audrey Redheart is (as Pure Evil). Any text from her Villains Wiki page in this proposal was written by me.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who's the character?
- 3 What makes her heinous? Does she pass the heinous standard?
- 4 What are her preventions?
- 5 Verdict
Wandersong is a usually relaxing video game about a singing bard who finds out that the decay of the world is occurring and that the final part in Eya's cycle of death and rebirth is nigh once again. They set out on an adventure to meet the Overseers and get them to tell the Bard their fragments of the Earthsong, a song said to repair the world. Along the way they meet Miriam, a curmudgeonly young witch who helps them in the…
IH Removal: Alph (Banjo-Tooie)
I was surprised to see him here and after checking the game I don't think his threat is enough to make him stand out, so here's a removal proposal for him. I have permission to make this from Dual89 Proxima.
- 1 The work?
- 2 Who is he?
- 3 Why doesn't he count?
- 4 Verdict?
Banjo-Tooie is a Nintendo 64 game by Rare and is a sequel to Banjo-Kazooie. In this game Gruntilda the witch has been freed with the help of her sisters, and Banjo and Kazooie travel to various worlds to stop her plan of draining the life from the Isle O'Hags in order to restore her body.
Alph is part of a crew of aliens whose UFO crashed in Jolly Roger's Lagoon. He needs your help fixing his ship, and then appears in Hailfire Peaks where he falls to his death, and Mumbo must restore him …
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Tom from The Holiday Mod
Hello, everybody. Here's my second Friday Night Funkin by BBpanzu. It's a mod which is in a Christmas theme with several stories. The first week is just Boyfriend and Girlfriend celebrating Christmas while also getting involved in a hostage situation. The second week involves them having to stop an arial terrorist (if you are familiar, you probably know who that is, but if you don't, it's Tom).
- 1 Who is He? What Has He Done?
- 2 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 3 Mitigating Factors?
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict
Thomas "Tom" Ridgewell is the main antagonist of Part 2 of the mod.
Tankman calls up Boyfriend and Girlfriend and says there's an arial terrorist that really hates Christmas and will destroy anything that has anything to do with it. So, they deci…
IH proposal:The Yandere from Notice Me Senpai.
To the attention of moderators, some part of this proposal come from her fanon villain page. However, since it was me who wrote the page it doesn't count as plagiarism so I ask you not to ban me for that please.
Okay, so this is my first IH proposal of the year. I've been pretty busy lately, so I haven't been able to do many proposals. However, I have several planned, so I'm going to start with an easy one.
- 1 What's the work ?
- 2 Who is The Yandere ? What she has done ?
- 3 Heinous standards.
- 4 What Make her Inconsistent ?
- 5 Verdict ?
Notice Me Senpai is a short Youtube music clip created by iHasCupquake. In this clip, we follow the story of a girl, whose names is unknown, obsessed with her "Senpai" to the point of stalking him and killing any potential ri…
IH Proposal: Viktor from Arcane
I recently wrapped up Arcane and I decided to propose what I feel will be another IH/IA after the Fire Punch duo. @GlitchProductionsFan handled the IA proposal but he said he was fine with me doing this so I shall.
- 1 What's The Work?
- 2 Who is the Character? What Has He Done?
- 3 Heinous Standards?
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict?
Arcane is the very good animated television series based on the digital salt-mining factory known as League of Legends. In the realm of Runeterra, the city of Piltover is vaulted for its technological and societal progress, but in truth has a dark underbelly in the under-city of Zaun, located on the other side of the bridge, where the poor and destitute live and are exploited as a labor source. Two sister, Vi and Jinx (…
IH Proposal: Guy Crimson
I thought of proposing an another That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime character and after binging enough the Light Novel to understand the changed heinous standard and newer vollains I can finally release Guy Crimson's proposal.
WARNING: There will be spoilers for those only seen Anime and Manga as I pulled info from the Light Novel so spoiler warnings ahead.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who the character?
- 3 Heinous Standard?
- 3.1 Heinous Acts
- 4 Preventions
- 5 Verdict
That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime is an light Novel about an worker who was reincarnated as a slime who formed an nation and befriended a dragon while trying to make a nation to enjoy his life enjoyable like in his old world. It also got Anime, Manga, and mobile & console games too.
Guy Crimson…
IH Proposal - The Virus Bot
Hello Everyone this is the guy with a dimenito pfp despite dimenito not really being my favorite character anymore, but anyways since I'm now whitelisted and able to make proposal or removals now, why don't I start off with The Virus Bot, let do this shit
- 1 What The Work
- 2 Who is The Virus Bot and What Have He's Done
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 Preventions
- 5 Verdict
Lost in Vyond is a live action type cartoon film where our hero (Cesar) have enter the vyond world and let just say brought a certain robot here to vyond to cause mayhem just from trying to go back to world, it now up to Tom and Cesar to tried to bring out hero back home and tried to stop the virus bot
The Virus Bot is of course the main villain of the film, he's was originally program to do go…
IH Proposal: Quasimodo Wilson from Hotel Transylvania
And we're back with another proposal. This time the character's from a place where monsters . . . yeah, it's a hotel for monsters.
- 1 What is Hotel Transylvania?
- 2 Who is Quasimodo?
- 3 What makes him Heinous
- 4 Heinous Standards
- 5 What makes him Inconsistent?
- 6 Final Verdict?
Hotel Transylvania is a franchise showcasing Dracula and company in a hotel. I won't go into too much about the 2nd to 4th films, so here's the first one:
Hotel Transylvania 1 involves Johnny finding the hotel, and Dracula has to make sure no one finds out who he really is. However, one guy saw through him, and it's Quasimodo Wilson.
Quasimodo Wilson is the hotel's head chef, cooking up the recipes for all the monsters there. Upon learning that Johnny somehow got in, he made it his mis…
Singed (Arcane): Inconsistently Heinous proposal
A huge thanks to Complete Monster for adding me to the whitelist. With the series wrapping up a few month's ago, I decided to do a rather easy qualifier from Arcane. This will probably be on the easiest keep's on this wiki.
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is Singed? What has he done?
- 3 Heinous Standard?
- 4 Redeeming Qualities?
- 5 Final Verdict?
Arcane: League of Legends is a Netflix tv show made by Riot studio, focusing on sisters Vi and Jinx and the conflict between cities Piltover and Zaun. One of the major villains in the series is the Zaunite mad scientist Singed who, despite being more sympathetic than his game counterpart, proves himself to be one of the series most heinous characters.
Dr. Corin Reveck was a revered scientist who actually used to be in Pil…
Garvey (Remastered version) IH Proposal
Hello everybody, I bring you an FNAF Fangame candidate, one which, is worth talking about in my eyes, so, let's get to it! Also, both a spoiler warning and a gore warning, as this game does get pretty bloody and is NOT for the faint of heart. Also, this is my first IH proposal in a blog post, so I am unsure if it will be high quality, but I tried my best,
- 1 What's the work?
- 2 Who is the character?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 4 What makes him inconsistent?
- 5 Heinous standards
- 6 One last thing
- 7 Conclusion?
Dormitabis Remastered is a remaster of the original Dormitabis. Dormitabis Remastered follows the main character John Write, surviving 12 nights in purgatory with various animatronics, and as the nights go on, more show up and get more aggressive, well, …
IH Proposal: Petey the Cat
, but there's a reason he's considered the evilest cat.]] Hello Inconsistently Heinous Wiki! Today I am making another Dog Man proposal, with it being my second out of four proposals I am currently thinking of making. I decided to put both Petey's movie and book counterpart into one proposal to make it more efficient instead of just making two separate proposals. Therefore, the formatting of this proposal will be a little different than most proposals, however it will still contain the necessary sections.
This will contain spoilers for the Dog Man movie, by the way.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who's the Character?
- 3 What Makes Him Heinous?
- 3.1 Both Incarnations
- 3.2 Book Petey
- 3.2.1 Super Diaper Baby 2: The Invasion of the Potty Snatchers
- 3.2.2 Dog Man
- 3.2.3 Dog Man U…
IH Proposal: King Immortal from Invincible
With my recent removal of Robot, I think it makes sense for me to add on a character in his place, that being the Immortal (more specifically, the future version of the character we see in episode 4 of the third series). This proposal will be on both the versions from the comic and show, although I recommend you look at both versions individually when voting.
- 1 What is the Work?
- 2 Who is the Character and What Has He Done
- 3 Heinous Standards
- 4 What Makes Him Inconsistent
- 5 Verdict
Copied and pasted from my previous proposals because I'm lazy
Invincible is an image comic homage to the superheroes of our childhood with a dark and violent twist. However, unlike something such as The Boys, Invincible doesn't straight-up parody its subject matter, and gene…
Inconsistently Heinous Proposal: Miss Grace from BlenTouad
Guys, I have another Fundamental Paper Education candidate and also sort of a Squid Game candidate. Just going to propose one more FPE villain for a navigation template to be allowed to be made.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is She?
- 3 What Makes Her Heinous?
- 3.1 What Has She Done?
- 3.2 Heinous Standards?
- 3.3 Mitigating Factors?
- 4 What Makes Her Inconsistent?
- 5 Verdict?
Fundamentals in Squid Games is a YouTube video by BlenTouad uploaded in 2025. It's a crossover of Fundamental Paper Education and Squid Game where FPE characters have to beat the Squid Games.
Miss Grace is the main antagonist. She is the principal of Paper School which, after it's in massive debt, she decides to use the Squid Games to get money.
When the school is in massive debt, Miss Grace decides to use the Sq…